48809bd3a5Adversarial review surfaced 9 critiques: 7 patched, 1 resolved by spike, 1 deferred. Most damaging: --comment/--dry-run flag inversion and fabricated dedup SHA-trailer mechanism — both indicated the change was written against the dep change's design rather than the shipped skill artifact. Artifacts: - new design.md with 12 decisions (D2 no-PR-head-checkout, D6 dedup, D7 ephemeral token, D9 dist split, D10 failure matrix, D11 skill invocation prompt, D12 --allowedTools whitelist) and Risks - new battle-test.md with critique inventory, dispositions, patches - proposal.md: corrected cost range, flag, --allowedTools detail - spec.md: 9 patches — split copy-paste vs uses: paths, no PR-head checkout, dedup contract, allowed-tools restriction, max_turns soft cap, PR# pass requirement C4 spike (2026-05-13) validated D2+D7 on Codeberg Forgejo v11.x. Ephemeral GITEA_TOKEN + permissions: pull-requests: write permits create_pull_review on fork PR; pull_request_target executes BASE workflow file (display label pull_request is cosmetic). Spike artifacts retained for reproducibility. C5 spike (cross-repo workflow_call) scaffolded but deferred; tracked in forgejo-mcp-33k. Cleanup of Codeberg test repos tracked in forgejo-mcp-p0y.
11 lines
1.7 KiB
JSON
11 lines
1.7 KiB
JSON
{"ts":"2026-05-12T15:14:51Z","phase":"any","event":"turn.start","input":"Battle-test proposal and design"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-12T15:14:56Z","phase":"any","event":"agent.spawned","kind":"battle-test","count":"2"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-12T19:53:21Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"battle-test.md"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-12T19:53:21Z","phase":"any","event":"turn.end","output":"Battle-test complete; see battle-test.md"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:07:00Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"proposal.md (patched: C1, C7, C9)"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:07:00Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"design.md (patched: D2 subsection, D6 rewrite, D7 stalemate marker, D9 split, D10 row+rationale, Risks rename+expand, new D11, new D12)"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:07:00Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"spec.md (patched: 2 new scenarios for distribution paths, --dry-run requirement, PR# pass scenario, max_turns rewrite + cost_usd scenario, scope warning scenario, NEW Dedup contract requirement, NEW Allowed tools requirement, NEW Base-only checkout requirement, Fork-PR clarification)"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:08:41Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"spikes/c4-ephemeral-token-fork-pr/"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:08:41Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"spikes/c5-cross-repo-workflow-call/"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:33:31Z","phase":"authoring","event":"artifact.added","ref":"C4 spike resolved (D2+D7 validated); design.md D7 + spec.md fork-PR scenario updated with evidence"}
|
|
{"ts":"2026-05-13T06:33:31Z","phase":"any","event":"turn.end","output":"Battle-test wrapped: 7 patches applied, C4 spike resolved, C5 spike deferred to forgejo-mcp-33k, cleanup tracked in forgejo-mcp-p0y"}
|