The A/B harness measured two regimes. bf16 loads (the Studio default on Ampere+)
are bit-identical with the flag on across all six families, 36/36 same-seed cases,
because the flag only changes fp16 GEMM accumulation. fp16 loads (the pre-Ampere
fallback dtype) show real same-seed drift on the families that genuinely run fp16
GEMMs: SDXL up to 0.050 mean abs diff, FLUX.1 0.028, FLUX.2-klein 0.045, all
finite, no new black frames. qwen-image renders black in fp16 with the flag off
too and z-image fp16 fails in attention, so both are dtype limitations, not
accumulation ones.
So the gate now takes the compute dtype and the speed tier: bf16 engages on any
active tier (provably output-neutral), fp16 engages only under max, the tier that
already trades exactness for measured speed. The deny-list stays empty by
measurement.
cf2b2e593e