Four valid review comments from gemini-code-assist[bot] on #5759:
1. core/rag/bm25.py:_load — wrap bm25s.BM25.load + json.loads with
specific exception handlers (FileNotFoundError, OSError,
JSONDecodeError, ValueError) and log a warning instead of
propagating a 500. Corrupt/partial bm25 dirs now degrade to
empty-search rather than crashing the request.
2. core/rag/tool.py was importing _resolve_scope_embedder from
routes/rag.py — a layering violation (core depending on
routes). Move the resolver into a new core/rag/scope.py module
along with the chat-settings key constants; routes/rag.py
now re-imports it under the same name. Same behaviour, no
cycle, one source of truth for the resolution logic.
3. core/rag/bm25.py:rebuild_index — call delete_scope before saving
the new index so stale files from a previous build (or a
bm25s naming change) never coexist with current files. The
library's save() doesn't unlink files it doesn't write.
4. routes/rag.py:_save_upload was running f.write() synchronously
inside an async def. Switch to anyio.open_file() so each chunk
write runs in a worker thread instead of blocking the event
loop on multi-MB uploads. Cleanup unlink happens after the
async-with closes the handle so Windows is happy.
Skipped one (vector_store.py:133 'hasattr query_points' redundancy)
— that comment was on the pre-rewrite Qdrant code; the file is
now sqlite-vec backed and the hasattr check is gone.
core/rag/db.py, vector_store.py, tool.py, bm25.py, and reranker.py
all run only in the FastAPI parent process. Switch their loggers
from Python stdlib to studio's structlog get_logger so their output
shows up in the same JSON stream as the rest of the backend (the
request_completed / RAG search lines).
embeddings.py and ingestion.py stay on stdlib because they execute
inside the mp.spawn ingestion subprocess, which doesn't inherit the
parent's structlog configuration.
The query was always going through the default text embedder
(bge-small, 384-d) regardless of how the scope was ingested. A
multimodal thread indexed by Qwen3-VL (2048-d) crashed at cosine
similarity with 'shapes (104,2048) and (384,) not aligned'.
Resolve the scope's embedder at search time:
- kb_<id> -> rag_knowledge_bases.embedding_model column
- thread_<id> -> thread settings (with fallback to defaults +
RAG_EMBEDDER_MATRIX matrix lookup)
Pass it through retrieve_hybrid/retrieve_dense to embeddings.encode
so the query lands in the same vector space as the docs. Both the
/api/rag/search route and the search_knowledge_base tool use the
same resolver.
- chat-adapter pre-fetches retrieval on every turn when RAG is on,
regardless of provider. Users no longer have to phrase queries as
'the document I attached' for retrieval to fire. Local tool models
still get search_knowledge_base registered as a refinement path.
- New per-thread ragMinScore slider (Min relevance, 0..1) gates
retrieved hits by dense cosine similarity. Hits below the floor
(and BM25-only hits with no dense signal) are dropped server-side
so unrelated docs don't get injected when the user's query is
off-topic from what's indexed.
- Backend logs at search start (scope, top_k, min_score, query
preview), after retrieval (retrieved vs met_threshold counts),
and on return (final hit count) for both /api/rag/search and the
search_knowledge_base tool path.
- System-prompt nudge prepended when pre-fetch returns hits so the
model knows to cite [1], [2] rather than paraphrase silently.
Promotes RAG to a first-class composer toggle alongside Think / Web
Search / Code, with tool-use semantics on local models that support
tools and a pre-fetch fallback on external providers. The model
decides when to call `search_knowledge_base` on local inference; on
external providers retrieval still fires before each message (the
existing pre-fetch path), gated on the same button.
Backend
- core/rag/tool.py (new): search_knowledge_base handler + JSON-schema
tool spec. Resolves scope (kb_id wins over thread_id) from the
request's rag_scope, runs retrieve_hybrid + optional rerank, then
hydrates filename / page_number / text from sqlite and formats as
numbered Markdown citations ('[1] file.pdf (page 5): ...') for the
LLM to cite. Empty scope returns a user-facing hint; empty results
return a clear no-match message instead of an empty string.
- core/inference/tools.py: SEARCH_KNOWLEDGE_BASE_TOOL added to
ALL_TOOLS (lazy import keeps tools.py importable on inference
paths that never touch RAG). execute_tool() gains a tool_context
parameter that carries per-request extras the LLM doesn't see
(currently just rag_scope). The new 'search_knowledge_base' branch
dispatches to the handler with scope unpacked from tool_context.
- core/inference/llama_cpp.py + safetensors_agentic.py +
orchestrator.py: thread tool_context through generate_chat_completion_
with_tools / run_safetensors_tool_loop / execute_tool. Both local
backends (GGUF llama-server and safetensors agentic) carry the same
context object.
- models/inference.py: ChatCompletionRequest gains optional
rag_scope: dict ({kb_id?, thread_id?, enable_rerank?, default_top_k?,
reranker_model?}). Ignored unless 'search_knowledge_base' is in
enabled_tools.
- routes/inference.py: both the GGUF and safetensors call sites for
generate_chat_completion_with_tools forward payload.rag_scope into
tool_context.
Frontend
- chat-runtime-store.ts: global ragToolEnabled boolean + setter +
CHAT_RAG_TOOL_ENABLED_KEY localStorage, mirroring toolsEnabled /
codeToolsEnabled. Settings-hydration migration auto-flips
ragToolEnabled=true for pre-Phase-4 users who already had ragSource
set, so existing RAG users don't silently lose retrieval on upgrade.
- shared-composer.tsx: new 'RAG' pill button after Images (uses
lucide BookOpenIcon, composer-pill-btn style, data-active toggle).
Disabled when no model is loaded. Toggling on from ragSource='off'
auto-flips source to 'thread' so the sidebar lands ready-to-go.
- chat-adapter.ts:
* The existing pre-fetch block is now gated on ragToolEnabled AND
only fires when the tool path isn't viable (external provider OR
local model without tool-use support). Tool-capable local models
skip pre-fetch and let the LLM decide.
* The local-model body assembly adds 'search_knowledge_base' to
enabled_tools and packs ragSource + enableRerank + ragTopK into a
rag_scope object the backend tool handler consumes.
- chat-settings-sheet.tsx: entire Retrieval CollapsibleSection is
wrapped in {ragToolEnabled && ...} so it hides when the button is
off — the button is now the single on/off control. The 'Off'
option is removed from the Source dropdown (the button handles
that). Default open when shown so settings are one click away.
Tests
- test_rag_tool_handler.py: handler covers empty query, missing
scope, kb_id > thread_id precedence, thread-only path, citation
formatting (numbered + page numbers + unknown source); tool spec
shape (function/name/required); execute_tool dispatch with and
without tool_context; ALL_TOOLS includes the new spec without
dropping the existing ones.
Verification scope
- Local GGUF with tools: toggle button on, upload doc, ask about
doc content → assistant emits a search_knowledge_base tool call
card (rendered by the existing ToolFallback component since no
custom UI exists yet — that's a v2 nice-to-have).
- External provider (Anthropic / OpenAI / etc.): same button, same
UX, but uses the pre-fetch path under the hood.
- Migration: pre-existing ragSource != off → button initializes ON
so retrieval keeps working.
